The cliffhanger ending of Season 1 left the story wide open for another season. "It lends itself to that, for sure," Kaley Cuoco told Glamour. "Chris [Messina] and I obviously would love to do a season two. I think there's a lot more story to tell, a lot more [hijinks], silliness, comedy. We would absolutely be down for that." Cuoco also said she's open to her character, Ava, exploring a much darker arc in Season 2, she told Entertainment Weekly.
"I love acting with Kaley," Messina told Collider. "She made me better. I would love to learn more from her and just get to hang with her. I'd like to see a Bonnie and Clyde thing with them, where they just make worse and worse decisions and stupider mistakes that send them deeper into the hole. It would be fun to get another shot at playing with that."
Tom Bateman told Entertainment Weekly when he was first approached about joining the cast, multiple seasons were already planned out. "He's [Craig Rosenberg] really got this plan mapped out in his head," Bateman told Entertainment Weekly. "I feel that with where it ends, Season 1 is just so delicious. And you think, 'Let's have a second helping of that, please.'" The WGA strike poses a problem; even if a second season is greenlit by Peacock, we likely won't see it soon.