"Impractical Jokers" co-host Joseph Quinn, better known as Q, discussed some of the uncertainty surrounding the show's future on a January 2023 episode of the "Tell 'em Steve-Dave!" podcast, which he also co-hosts. He mentioned that Season 11 wasn't a sure thing and that the show's viewership had dropped for the first time.

Meanwhile, in September 2023, Joker Sal Vulcano spoke to The Cincinnati Enquirer ahead of a stand-up comedy appearance. "We're negotiating," he said in response to a question about Season 11. "We're trying to see now if we're going to get more seasons. I remain positive, one way or the other. I'm positive we'll have some good news coming, maybe."

As it turns out, Vulcano's optimism may have been warranted. In a December 2023 episode of his podcast "Taste Buds," he mentioned a giveaway, the winner of which will receive a trip to visit the set of "Impractical Jokers." Assuming this means new work on that set will soon be underway, it's the clearest sign that Season 11 is coming outside of an official announcement. For now, Q, Vulcano, and their "Impractical Jokers" co-star James Murray are set to return in new episodes of Season 10 at some point in 2024.